News

Nicholas Griffin QC comments on Supreme court judgement on diplomatic immunity in trafficking case
18.10.2017

The Supreme Court today handed down judgement in the case of Reyes v Al-Malki and another [2017] UKSC 61, a decision on diplomatic immunity. A Saudi diplomat in London, who was no longer in post, was able to benefit from a narrower form of immunity than those in post. That immunity did not cover allegations of serious maltreatment made against him and his wife by a Filipino domestic worker, brought to the UK to work for them in London.

The case is at its most interesting – and disturbing – where it considers whether the seriousness of allegations of this sort should have a bearing on the availability of diplomatic immunity for those still in post. The allegations in this case included excessive work without payment, confiscation of her passport and stopping her from leaving the house and communicating with others (until she escaped). Lord Sumption (with Lord Neuberger agreeing) believed on a proper interpretation of the law that the diplomat would have been entitled to immunity had he remained in post, notwithstanding the serious nature of the allegations. Lord Wilson (Lady Hale and Lord Clarke agreeing), was less sure – and was pleased the court did not formally have to address the question. In a powerful judgment, he noted that the UK confronts a significant problem in relation to the exploitation of migrant domestic workers by foreign diplomats and further noted the universality of the international community’s determination to combat human trafficking. He stated also that “it is difficult for this court to forsake what it perceives to be a legally respectable solution and instead to favour a conclusion that its system cannot provide redress for an apparently serious case of domestic servitude here in our capital city.”

It is therefore grimly coincidental that this decision comes out on Anti-Slavery Day. The Anti-Slavery Day Act 2010 introduced this national day to raise awareness of the need to eradicate all forms of slavery, human trafficking and exploitation.

For further detail follow this link: https://www.supremecourt.uk/cases/uksc-2016-0023.html


Nicholas Griffin QC

News:

SELECT TOP(10) ChildSite.SitePageId, ChildSite.PageFolder, ChildSite.PageName, ChildSite.PageType, CFTitle.CustomInformationValue, CFDescript.CustomInformationValue, CFDate.CustomInformationValue, CFCat.CustomInformationValue, CaseDate = CASE WHEN Len(CFDate.CustomInformationValue) < 1 THEN null ELSE CAST(SUBSTRING(CFDate.CustomInformationValue,7,4) + '-' + SUBSTRING(CFDate.CustomInformationValue,4,2) + '-' + SUBSTRING(CFDate.CustomInformationValue,1,2)AS DATETIME) END FROM tblSitePage ParentSite INNER JOIN tblLinkPage LinkPage ON (ParentSite.SitePageId = LinkPage.pageID) INNER JOIN tblSitePage ChildSite ON (LinkPage.linkPageID = ChildSite.SitePageId) INNER JOIN tblCustomFieldInformation CFTitle ON ChildSite.SitePageId = CFTitle.SitePageId AND CFTitle.CustomFieldId = 1 INNER JOIN tblCustomFieldInformation CFDescript ON ChildSite.SitePageId = CFDescript.SitePageId AND CFDescript.CustomFieldId = 2 INNER JOIN tblCustomFieldInformation CFCat ON ChildSite.SitePageId = CFCat.SitePageId AND CFCat.CustomFieldId = 3 INNER JOIN tblCustomFieldInformation CFDate ON ChildSite.SitePageId = CFDate.SitePageId AND CFDate.CustomFieldId = 4 WHERE ParentSite.SitePageId =601 AND ParentSite.PageStatus Like 'Live' AND ParentSite.PageLevel = 4 AND ChildSite.PageStatus Like 'Live' AND ChildSite.PageLevel = 4 ORDER BY CaseDate DESC, ChildSite.PageOrder, hildSite.PageName

QEB News: David Jeremy QC defends Jeffrey Barry on murder charge
10.11.2017 More >

QEB News: Eleanor Laws QC, one of the Bar Council’s Lead Facilitators for Vulnerable Witness Training, is providing training in a number of upcoming events
31.10.2017 More >

QEB News: Crispin Aylett QC - Chambers UK Crime Silk of the Year 2017
26.10.2017 More >

QEB News: Susannah Stevens represents police officer in gross misconduct proceedings
26.10.2017 More >

QEB News: Susannah Stevens represents nurse facing contempt of court proceedings
20.10.2017 More >

QEB News: Nicholas Griffin QC comments on Supreme court judgement on diplomatic immunity in trafficking case
18.10.2017 More >

QEB News: Edward Brown QC and Fraser Coxhill act for Core Participants in Independent Inquiry into Child Sexual Abuse
9.10.2017 More >

QEB News: Recent Developments in the law of Gross Negligence Manslaughter – Hosted by the Royal Society of Medicine, the BMA and the CPS.
04.10.2017 More >

QEB News: Tom Kark QC speaking at Regulation of Healthcare Professionals Conference 2017
19.09.2017 More >

QEB News: Trial of alleged 'grooming gang' starts in Newcastle
23.08.2017 More >

QEB News: Nicholas Griffin QC appointed to UK Anti-Doping Board
21.08.2017 More >

QEB News: Supreme Court rules sale of 'grey-market' goods a criminal offence
4.08.2017 More >

QEB News: Paul Wakerley represents GMC in misconduct hearing of consultant haematologist
28.07.17 More >

QEB News: Marvyn Iheanacho convicted of murder of five year old stepson
21.07.2017 More >

QEB News: Viscount jailed for racist and menacing Facebook post against anti-Brexit campaigner
13.07.2017 More >

QEB News: Selva Ramasamy represents surgeon in inquiry into death following surgery
07.07.2017 More >

QEB News: Independent Jersey Care Inquiry reports - expert evidence of Nicholas Griffin QC
04.07.2017 More >

QEB News: Successful Application to Dismiss and Motion to Quash in Modern Slavery case
30.06.2017 More >

QEB News: Mark Aldred comments on the liability of 999 response drivers
30.06.2017 More >

QEB News: SFO charges Barclays Bank and four executives with fraud
20.06.2017 More >

QEB News: Philip Evans QC has been appointed as the Rugby Football Union's second independent Head of Rugby Judiciary.
12.06.2017 More >

QEB News: Managing Director (Michael Holland) and Site Foreman convicted of Gross Negligence Manslaughter and Health and Safety offences
8.06.2017 More >

QEB News: Zoe Johnson QC and Philip McGhee prosecute baby shaking manslaughter
1.06.2017 More >

QEB News: Polly Dyer acts for FCA to secure Operation Cotton confiscation orders
25.05.2017 More >

QEB News: Prime Minister approves the appointment of Nick Griffin QC to the Security Vetting Appeals Panel.
5.04.2017 More >

QEB News: Fraser Coxhill presents the case for the GMC against Doctor suspended for dishonesty concerning inquiry into ‘Ebola nurse’ Pauline Cafferkey.
31.03.2017 More >

QEB News: Kidnapping Acquittal
31.3.2017 More >

QEB News: Rhys Meggy successfully defends regulated sector money laundering
03.01.2017 More >

QEB News: Rhys Meggy appears at the Court of Appeal in tax evasion
03.01.2017 More >

QEB News: Ex Black Rock portfolio manager imprisoned.
21.12.2016 More >

QEB News: Offshore Tax Evasion - civil and criminal sanctions
20.12.2016 More >

QEB News: Dr F, acquitted of serious sexual assault upon a male patient.
12.12.2016 More >

QEB News: Tom Kark prosecutes four in machine gun murder in Harlesden at Central Criminal Court.
12.12.2016 More >

QEB News: Two imprisoned for illegal harvesting and distribution of international premium sports broadcasts
09.12.2016 More >

QEB News: RDC (The Regulatory Decisions Committee) direct FCA to revoke prohibition order
28.11.2016 More >

QEB News: Ex Black Rock portfolio manager pleads guilty to insider dealing charges
7.11.2016 More >

QEB News: Paedophile police superintendent jailed for 12 years - Eleanor Laws QC prosecutes
4.11.2016 More >

QEB News: Tom Kark QC and Alexandra Felix represent GMC in Dr Waney Squier's appeal
3.11.2016 More >

QEB News: Fishermen’s Friends Manslaughter Trial
3.11.2016 More >

QEB News: Tom Kark QC and John Lynch train the GMC legal team in Manchester
31.10.2016 More >

QEB News: Sean Larkin QC shortlisted for Crime Silk of the Year by Legal 500 Bar Awards 2017
21.10.2016 More >

QEB News: Eleanor Laws QC prosecutes former senior policeman for historic sex offences
21.10.2016 More >

QEB News: David Jeremy QC defends man accused of murdering his girlfriend
21.10.2016 More >

QEB News: Crispin Aylett QC prosecutes alleged killer of police constable
9.10.16 More >

QEB News: David Groome and Ari Alibhai secure confiscation order for nearly £1m against directors of Digicam on behalf of FA Premier League and Sky.
30.09.2016 More >

QEB News: Susannah Stevens successfully defends former public school House Master accused of sexual assault.
23.09.2016 More >

QEB News: Paul Raudnitz considers Deferred Prosecution Agreements in the light of the first two cases.
23.09.2016 More >

QEB News: Inquiry into the Iraq Historic Allegations Team (‘IHAT’), led by Sir David Calvert-Smith, publishes report.
16.09.2016 More >

QEB News: Dan Hollis 1925 – 2016
05.09.2016 More >

QEB News: Bella Coates analyses the government’s Action Plan for tackling money laundering and terrorist funding
17.05.2016 More >

QEB News: Paul Wakerley represents care home manager charged in connection with the death of a patient
13.07.2016 More >

QEB News: David Spens QC represents senior partner of small commercial firm in Court of Appeal
08.07.2016 More >

QEB News: Nick Corsellis represents Professional Tennis Integrity Officers in anti-corruption hearing
08.07.2016 More >

QEB News: Zoe Johnson QC and Paul Raudnitz instructed in landmark Deferred Prosecution Agreement case - "SFO v XYZ Ltd"
08.07.2016 More >

QEB News: Barclays Libor
04.07.2016 More >

QEB News: Edward Brown QC and Ben Fitzgerald represent prosecution in Ben Butler murder trial
21.06.2016 More >

QEB News: Prosecution offer no evidence after complainant's evidence discredited in fraud and money laundering trial
20.06.2016 More >

QEB News: Selva Ramasamy and Tom Coke-Smyth speak at Army Professional Training Conference
02.06.2016 More >

QEB News: Edward Henry acts for Company Director in appeal against disqualification
24.05.2016 More >

QEB News: Selva Ramasamy prosecutes struck off solicitor for SRA
31.05.2016 More >

QEB News: Zoe Johnson QC and Philip Stott represent GP Dr Rudling charged with gross negligence manslaughter
31.05.2016 More >

QEB News: Mark Aldred speaks at Police Federation Annual Conference
18.05.2016 More >

QEB News: Nicholas Griffin QC speaks at the Covert Policing RIPA 2000 conference
12.05.2016 More >

QEB News: Katherine Buckle is part of the legal team appearing in the two day Privy Council hearing of Hernandez and Pitman v State of Trinidad and Tobago.
17.05.2016 More >

QEB News: Two convicted and three acquitted in the ‘biggest ever insider trading trial’. Mark Ellison QC and Tom Broomfield acted for the prosecution and William Boyce QC acted for the defence.
12.05.2016 More >

QEB News: Edward Henry appeared on behalf of the Earl of Cardigan at Swindon Crown Court in his appeal against conviction for a public order offence.
11.05.2016 More >

QEB News: Paul Raudnitz presents Dr Adler case for the GMC
09.05.2016 More >