RMD v General Medical Council [2026] EWHC 2684 (Admin)

Lydia Barnfather successfully challenged interim conditions imposed on a doctor's registration, securing their revocation by the High Court.

The High Court has ruled in favour of a medical practitioner on an application under section 41A(10)(b) of the Medical Act 1983 and revoked in full the interim conditions imposed by the Interim Orders Tribunal (IOT).

The doctor faced serious allegations concerning conduct in two private relationships, which were denied. Following a police investigation that concluded without charges, the IOT imposed notification conditions which were further added to at a review hearing in June 2026, including an additional restriction on face-to-face consultations with female patients.

Lydia challenged the conditions on three grounds: that they were not necessary for public protection, were not justified in the public interest and were disproportionate.

The High Court found in favour of the doctor on all three grounds, concluding the IOT was wrong to impose conditions on grounds of public protection as there was no evidence of any real immediate risk to patients. Allegations strictly confined to private adult relationships absent any impact on clinical conduct or patient safety cannot justify restricting a medical practitioner’s practice. In respect of which point the Legally Qualified Chair had erroneously referenced the case law and misdirected the IOT. The Court found the IOT wrong to impose conditions on public interest grounds because amongst other things the high threshold had not been met. The IOT had furthermore inappropriately relied upon an uncorroborated police log entry regarding a third woman of which the doctor had no notice, and which did not in any event met the evidential threshold. Had the conditions otherwise been justified, the Court would additionally have found them to be disproportionate given the severe practical impact upon the doctor’s practice. The condition prohibiting face-to-face consultations with female patients was found unsupported by any evidence of boundary-related risk in a clinical setting.

The Court ordered that all interim conditions be revoked.

Main take-away points:

  • Serious allegations concerning a doctor's private life do not, without more, establish a risk to patients sufficient to justify interim restrictions on public protection grounds.
  • Interim conditions must be properly justified on public protection or public interest grounds and appropriately supported by evidence.
  • Tribunals must consider the practical and professional consequences of interim restrictions when assessing proportionality.

Lydia Barnfather was instructed by Surjit Dubb of Hempsons LLP.

Contact our experts for further advice